let's begin. This bug was my first report. I tried to start Bug Bounty in 2023, but I gave up and started learning marketing. I was selling cars to dealers for commission using scripts posted in Facebook groups.

But I wanted to deeper more academic way, and I wanted to create Twitter ads to learn from the dashboard. This was in May 2024, but before I could open the dashboard, it showed me I needed to add valid payment card because I couldn't access the dashboard without payment card and verify my account with premium subscription. So I tried adding payment card from the Generator Card site.

Twitter Ads payment form, with the email pixelated.
  • And it failed ;(
Twitter Ads rejects the card information as invalid.
  • But when I try to edit the url and create ad, it redirects me normally!
Twitter Ads campaign objective selection.

But when I chose the type of ad and completed everything, but instead of clicking on create I clicked on save draft, this image appeared to me: if you notice, it tell "We will complete verification in 24-48 hours."

Twitter Ads says verification is underway and will complete in 24–48 hours.

Then, when I go to the Campaign page i see this

Campaign listed with pending Premium verification and zero spend.

first I didn't notice, I thought it was just from the UI and nothing more, but the next day I was surprised to find that my account had been verified!

Eyad’s account shows verified since May 2024; the profile bio is pixelated.

At that time, I didn't understand what happened, and this was because I had stopped working in that field. when I contacted my friend @hackieng . Shoutout he really helped me a lot. I joined him on Call Discord on same day, and we started writing the report and trying to improve the impact.

By creating another account under the name NahamSec and attempting to verify it The next day, NahamSec account was verified For while, but then it was banned.

The test account described in the writeup using NahamSec’s name and branding.

This means that what happened could happen to many companies. When Twitter first launched verification subscription, many people were verified using the names of famous companies like "Eli Lilly". This Forbes article discussed how this fake account was verified using the company name, causing 4.37% drop in the stock price.

Forbes headline about the fake Eli Lilly account and the 4.37 percent stock decline.

Here, the impact no longer limited to millions in financial losses due to free lifetime account verification (Still my account verified from 2024). It could also damage Twitter again.

The response was very quick after reporting on HackerOne in less than 48 hours, the vulnerability was fix, and month later, we received $500 bounty.

HackerOne notification for report 2530534 about Twitter Premium after a failed payment.

Did you think I was going to earn huge number or something? When we asked what the report was assessed on, in my opinion it was critical or high, but the team response was ridiculous. Yes I scammed.

X’s HackerOne response explains its Low severity assessment and bounty decision.

And really, if you have monitoring systems, how my account and @hackieng account verified? I didn't understand what he mean by "when to issue complimentary premium," but generally, my account and my friend account are still verified for free.

we then submitted mediation request, but as usual, HackerOne doesn't care about bug hunters. Since August 2024, the mediation request still open.

I think if someone else had submitted this report, they wouldn't have been treated with the same neglect and scam that happened to me. It would better for me to sell the bug on the dark web ;)

But honestly, after this vulnerability, I got excited to return to the field again, and after that, the bounties started pouring in.

As bad as the treatment was, this coincidence brought me back with Bug Bounty. Bug Bounty truly changed my life.