Hi, I’m Eyad a security researcher. This is my experience with Alchemy bug bounty program on Cantina, and honestly, it started really well.

Then I kept hunting, and things got weird lol.

1. First hour first bug $2,000


in my first hour hunting on Alchemy, I found a business logic bug:

When you subscribe to Pay As You Go they charged $5 to your card.

I checked the request body and found this field:

"stripe_payment_method_id": "xxxx"

I tried removing it. Rejected. A fake ID? Rejected. null? Also rejected.

Then I tried an empty string:

"stripe_payment_method_id": ""

Accepted. The plan activated without the payment method and the 5$.

I submitted the report, and about five hours later, on the same day, they fixed it and gave me $2,000. The severity was Medium.

$2,000, Medium, and a same-day payout. This was a really good start.
same day payout. This was really cool (;

I was impressed. fast fix, fast payout. I thanked them in the report because that was a really good first experience.

So, of course, I kept working.

2. email HTML injection


The next day, I submitted a simple HTML injection in an email.

The reply was basically that it wasn’t in their infrastructure, and they closed the report.

okay But explain that to me. What exactly makes the issue outside the program?

I replied, and hours later the earlier comment was gone from the thread. Then I tried to dispute the decision, like mediation on HackerOne.

What happened? The Alchemy client changed the status back from Disputed to Acknowledged and locked the finding.

How am I supposed to see that as dispute if the client can close the dispute? I am asking for help with the client decision, and the client is the one ending the discussion.

  • That was my first problem with the experience on Cantina.

3. IDOR in Usage Limit


I also found an IDOR in Usage Limit Management. I could change another organization spending limits. That could stop its users from spending and interrupt their usage.

I reported estimated Impact of 57,000+ accounts, including enterprise users.

At first, they told me the issue was a duplicate. But the report linked as the duplicate was marked Rejected, and I couldn’t see the title.

My report: Duplicate. The linked report: Rejected. I asked them to explain.
My report: Duplicate. The linked report: Rejected. I asked them to explain.

I asked them to explain. They said they couldn’t disclose the earlier report.

after few hours I checked again and the bug appeared fixed. So I went back to the report and asked: the issue is fixed now, can you confirm my submission?

Then they reopened it:
After that, the severity became Medium. I disagreed. From the impact considered it High
  • ended up lowest medium bounty payout listed in the table $1,000 ;(

Honestly, I felt cheated by how this was handled. First Duplicate then the bug gets fixed, then the report is reopened, then Medium. I had to keep pushing just to get the issue acknowledged.

4. Removing another users payment method


I submitted another report was simple "IDOR" issue I could remove another users saved payment method.

  • I found it while testing the DELETE request:
DELETE /api/billing/XXXXX HTTP/2
Host: XXXX

{"paymentMethodId":"pm_victim_id"}

Think about the impact: it could interfere with Alchemy collecting payment and could interrupt the affected user workflow when billing failed.

  • That report didn’t get a bounty either ;(

5. Breaking Alchemy Billing: Unlimited Free Credits


During the same week, I also found a billing bug that let me generate credits after failed payments and use those credits for products.

  • That one needs its own story so I put it in Part 2.

For the week of hunting, I eventually received $5,000 in total. Some of the decisions and payments took much longer than that week.

6. Nearly 11 Months in Review Seriously, Cantina?


This report is from a different program on Cantina.

I submitted it on November, 2025. It’s still showing In Review. eleven months later lol.

Report #91 in a different Cantina program. Still In Review.

I tried to get help from Cantina multiple times but just they ignored me.

So yes, I think Cantina needs a lot of improvement. The long reviews, the unclear decisions, and the way my disputes ended made me lose trust in the platform.

I started this by praising how fast Alchemy handled my first report. I meant that. But after everything that followed, I don’t plan to spend more time hunting on Cantina.